Sell us your Magic The Gathering cards

Sell us your Magic The Gathering cards.

We buy collections no matter how large.

What We Buy:

We buy all Magic The Gathering cards Alpha/Beta to the latest sets. Large and small collections. We are most interested in sets that are in great condtion. We are also looking to purchase any and all original  art used in the production of MTG cards.
For our current Standard and Modern Buy List follow this link:

How To Sell To Us:

Any cards on our Buy-List you can just bring to either store during business hours. 
For older expensive cards or collections:
In Columbia call us at 410-381-2732 and ask for Keegan.
Or in Mount Airy call 301-829-1017 and ask for Keegan.
You can reach us Monday-Saturday from 12 noon to 8 pm EST and Sunday 12 noon to 6 pm.
Or you can Email Keegan at

Via Email:

You can email us your collection list and after looking over your list we will contact you to let you know our level of interest.
We may make an offer or request other information
In most cases we will need to see the MTG cards in person to make an offer. In these cases you can bring the cards to the store. 
If you are too far a way for this to be feasible then you can mail your MTG cards insured to:
Comics To Astonish
9400 Snowden River Parkway
Suite 112
Columbia, MD 21045
Once we receive the cards we will either email or call you to let you know they arrived. We will go over the collection which may take up to a week due to high volume of collections we receive. Once we have assessed the collection we will make an offer. If we can’t come to an agreed on price we will mail your books back to you via USPS insured mail at our cost.

Bring Your Collection to the Store

You can bring your singles to either store any day of the week. (For larger collections or older expensive cards you must contact Keegan).
You may also email Keegan at or call the store at 410-381-2732 to set up a different time to meet at either store.

We Will Come To You:

For larger collections that can’t be brought to the store or for sellers who are unable drive we will come to you. This is done on a case by case basis and will depend on several factors. You can email us at or call the store at 410-381-273 with questions.
If you have any questions please feel free to email us at